It’s Time To Put Up That Statue

channys6thswan

Lingers Long On Cank Street
No, not to Vardy, or Claudio, though both definitely deserve one.
But a plain granite obelisk to mark the falling away of the football club we all love.

One day, someone smarter and better connected than any of us will write a book about the recent history of Leicester City, from the 2018/19 season through to 2026/27. 2018/19, because that season spanned both the unbelievably tragic loss of Vichai, and the arrival of TCR. 2026/27, because that’s when our on and off the field woes could really deepen, if as seems increasingly likely, we find ourselves back in the Third Tier. There are so many ways of telling that eight year story. From the perspective of financial mismanagement. About the lack of stadium, and the excess of training facility, development. About the lengthening parade of team managers, some arguably among the worst in our history. About the increasingly incomprehensible approach to wider football management. Even about the deteriorating relationship between the leadership of the club and its supporters. Every one of us will have their own take on each. I want to briefly put in my six penny worth on one key aspect of all that - transfer dealings.

- Our smart business model (of bringing two or three promising players in, and (more than) balancing that cost by selling one star at an inflated price) was still in place at the beginning of 18-19. In came Maddison, Pereira and Cags. Out went Mardy Mahrez.
- The smart model started to wobble slightly in 2019/20. In came Ayoze Perez and Praet and Justin, out went Maguire. Crucially, our recurrent failure to do anything meaningful in the January window really hurt us, and TCR, with Ryan Who? coming in on loan (Silva had been the only marquee signing to come in during a January window since the Title win, and that only because of the 14 seconds fax disaster in the summer of 2017).
- The next season (2020/21) showed that our smart model was not quite gone, but in trouble (Castagne, Fofana in, Chilwell out, though letting Bassey go for nowt, and DeMardy Gray for very little were worrying signs).
- 21/22 was when things really started to crash. Daka, Soumare and Firegaard expensively in, all again on big contracts, Ghezzal, the Newport County cup hero ( haha) the only name out the door, his refunded bus fare to who cares where, the only cash coming back to the club.
- 22/23 brought in another set of disasters, with bombscares, uneven quality, or bad fits coming in (Faes, Kristiansen, Souttar), while Fofana (70 mil, yes) and Schmeichel (oh, no) left.
- 23/24 reconfirmed the new model (poor value in, quality out) with the arrival of the likes of Winks, Coady and Cannon and the departure of Maddison, Barnes, and Castagne. The bigger story, though, in terms of the new, unsustainable, transfer model, was the start of the departure of big name, highly paid players who had sat out their fat contracts, and left for nothing (Tielemanns, Cags, Perez, Mendy, Amartey).
- 2024/25 revealed how the earlier collapse of the old transfer and contract model was now badly hurting the club. A mixed bag came in (Fatawu and El K the highlights, Holding the (bargaining chip) lowlight). Combined, they cost more than the departing KDH brought in, and once again, we were left with big fat contract sitters staying on, rather than going for a fee.
- This season, a couple of loans in, and more than expected for the departing dross. That enforced return to a more sensible business model came too late, however, for PSR, and only contributed to a further squad weakening. And the problem of the long list of huge contract holders still holidaying at Seagrave hasn’t gone away.

We once had it cracked. Now the whole thing is cracked. The monument should have a crack in it, too.
 
Very good summary of our implosion.
That 23/24 window was horrendously unbalanced. Some real talent going out and being replaced with some real dross.

It's a long and sad indictment of a club that's totally lost it's way.
 
The dross is our loss, we failed on our scouting abilities to find talent worthy of our sales there was no justification in allowing good players to drift away without good incomers.
That is down to rank bad management nothing more nothing less, they are like the Marie Celeste wandering without any sense of direction
 
Top post Channy .. the heart of the problem was the summer of 2021 after we had won the cup (but failed to qualify for the champions league), Top pressed the gamble button. I suspect Rodgers was very strongly in his ear, but whatever the reason it was Top who took the final decision. That opened up the risk of big PSR problems, and led directly to where we are now.
 
Our demise is heartbreaking. We had everything in place to be an established Premier League club with regular top half table finishes & winning cups being our route into Europe & whatever could follow from that.

That it has happened in such a short space of time makes it even worse. 3 years ago we were in a European semi final, 5000 of us in Rome full of optimism with a team & squad full of stars. Rodgers somehow managed to get that team relegated & it's been a rapid downhill descent ever since.

Just think back to Rome, we were top dogs in the area, Cov didn't have a ground, Forest treading water towards the lower end of the Championship, Derby in or heading for Div 1 & little hope for any of them from their fans. The roles have completely reversed now, mainly because those 3 clubs have new or proactive owners whilst ours is nowhere to be seen & hasn't got a clue anyway.

The state of our club is now at the level it was pre Milan Mandaric & I feel the downward turn under the present ownership & administration is only going to get worse.

So very sad & all caused by complete incompetence
 
Nailed it. For me it all points to a few things that could all have been easily avoided.

1. Losing at Forest in the cup.

2. Sticking with Ward as keeper and not giving Iversen a chance (see point 1).

3. Rodgers and his stupidity at not making any substitutions in the game v Brentford on what was a very hot day.

4. Not selling Tielemans when he’d just scored that cracker in the cup final. People say nobody wanted him. I find it hard to believe that no club in the whole of Europe wanted him or at that time would pay his wages.

Obviously not qualifying for the Champions League twice on the last day didn’t help us at all either.
 
4. Not selling Tielemans when he’d just scored that cracker in the cup final. People say nobody wanted him. I find it hard to believe that no club in the whole of Europe wanted him or at that time would pay his wages.
I thought clubs did want him but he felt they weren't big enough clubs. Fairly sure he didn't really want to go to Villa.
If that's the case then there is nothing the club can do to force a player to extend or leave, look at Liverpool and 'local legend' TAA.

Not excusing what has happened though.
 
This is total guesswork but I suspect the ‘plan’ in the summer of 2021 was to sell Tielemans. A combination of him not being keen to leave because none of the very biggest clubs were in for him. Top feeling some ‘loyalty’ because he had scored the goal in the cup final, the market being a bit depressed because of Covid and Rodgers telling everyone we needed to show ‘ambition’ to qualify for the champions leaguge. .. all taken together persuaded Top to ‘break’ the model and not sell anyone that summer.
We then bought badly, drifted down the table and PSR kicked in … the rest we all know.
 
This is total guesswork but I suspect the ‘plan’ in the summer of 2021 was to sell Tielemans. A combination of him not being keen to leave because none of the very biggest clubs were in for him. Top feeling some ‘loyalty’ because he had scored the goal in the cup final, the market being a bit depressed because of Covid and Rodgers telling everyone we needed to show ‘ambition’ to qualify for the champions leaguge. .. all taken together persuaded Top to ‘break’ the model and not sell anyone that summer.
We then bought badly, drifted down the table and PSR kicked in … the rest we all know.
I get where you’re coming from. But I still think that the collapse of the old ‘smart model’ started earlier than that. I’d date it back to the January window of 2020, when TCR was pushing for reinforcements for the league campaign to secure Champions League football, and the club only managed to bring in Ryan Bennett on loan. That was the first time the Club said no in a public way to Rodgers, and as history has shown, planting the seed of Board ‘disloyalty’ in his head always turns out badly. Complacency at the top of the club was also a factor, complacency about PSR kicking in for those in the then ‘Top 7’ (Man City and Chelsea already had their own rule book, and still have), and complacency around how consolidated our success had become. Add poor recruitment to the mix (yes, Congerton), a ‘write your own inflated contract for life’ habit, plus a focus on long term investment at the expense of the here and now (Seagraveyard) and the slow slide away from a well balanced recruitment/contracts/sales mix became an avalanche.
 
All valid points about failure on our part, but we must never forget that Man City cheated us out of Champions League football...
It's part of the demise.
 
I’d forgotten about the whole Ryan Bennett episode. An extremely odd signing at that time. How was he ever going to add that bit extra to get us into the top four?
 
No, not to Vardy, or Claudio, though both definitely deserve one.
But a plain granite obelisk to mark the falling away of the football club we all love.

One day, someone smarter and better connected than any of us will write a book about the recent history of Leicester City, from the 2018/19 season through to 2026/27. 2018/19, because that season spanned both the unbelievably tragic loss of Vichai, and the arrival of TCR. 2026/27, because that’s when our on and off the field woes could really deepen, if as seems increasingly likely, we find ourselves back in the Third Tier. There are so many ways of telling that eight year story. From the perspective of financial mismanagement. About the lack of stadium, and the excess of training facility, development. About the lengthening parade of team managers, some arguably among the worst in our history. About the increasingly incomprehensible approach to wider football management. Even about the deteriorating relationship between the leadership of the club and its supporters. Every one of us will have their own take on each. I want to briefly put in my six penny worth on one key aspect of all that - transfer dealings.

- Our smart business model (of bringing two or three promising players in, and (more than) balancing that cost by selling one star at an inflated price) was still in place at the beginning of 18-19. In came Maddison, Pereira and Cags. Out went Mardy Mahrez.
- The smart model started to wobble slightly in 2019/20. In came Ayoze Perez and Praet and Justin, out went Maguire. Crucially, our recurrent failure to do anything meaningful in the January window really hurt us, and TCR, with Ryan Who? coming in on loan (Silva had been the only marquee signing to come in during a January window since the Title win, and that only because of the 14 seconds fax disaster in the summer of 2017).
- The next season (2020/21) showed that our smart model was not quite gone, but in trouble (Castagne, Fofana in, Chilwell out, though letting Bassey go for nowt, and DeMardy Gray for very little were worrying signs).
- 21/22 was when things really started to crash. Daka, Soumare and Firegaard expensively in, all again on big contracts, Ghezzal, the Newport County cup hero ( haha) the only name out the door, his refunded bus fare to who cares where, the only cash coming back to the club.
- 22/23 brought in another set of disasters, with bombscares, uneven quality, or bad fits coming in (Faes, Kristiansen, Souttar), while Fofana (70 mil, yes) and Schmeichel (oh, no) left.
- 23/24 reconfirmed the new model (poor value in, quality out) with the arrival of the likes of Winks, Coady and Cannon and the departure of Maddison, Barnes, and Castagne. The bigger story, though, in terms of the new, unsustainable, transfer model, was the start of the departure of big name, highly paid players who had sat out their fat contracts, and left for nothing (Tielemanns, Cags, Perez, Mendy, Amartey).
- 2024/25 revealed how the earlier collapse of the old transfer and contract model was now badly hurting the club. A mixed bag came in (Fatawu and El K the highlights, Holding the (bargaining chip) lowlight). Combined, they cost more than the departing KDH brought in, and once again, we were left with big fat contract sitters staying on, rather than going for a fee.
- This season, a couple of loans in, and more than expected for the departing dross. That enforced return to a more sensible business model came too late, however, for PSR, and only contributed to a further squad weakening. And the problem of the long list of huge contract holders still holidaying at Seagrave hasn’t gone away.

We once had it cracked. Now the whole thing is cracked. The monument should have a crack in it, too.
i've said it before. we were like a family business going up against big box stores once we won the league on a shoestring. we should've brought in top people on the admin side who had big time experience, not relied on the bloke who once ran a lemonade stand for his local scout troop.
 
i've said it before. we were like a family business going up against big box stores once we won the league on a shoestring. we should've brought in top people on the admin side who had big time experience, not relied on the bloke who once ran a lemonade stand for his local scout troop.
Its easy to say that in hindsight but can you imagine the fans reaction to clearing them all out after all the success.
 
Had we booted Rudkin out and brought in someone with experience as Director of Football I don’t think anyone would have complained. It would have shown ambition.

Of course it may not have worked out but sticking with the same regime hasn’t exactly been a success.
 
Had we booted Rudkin out and brought in someone with experience as Director of Football I don’t think anyone would have complained. It would have shown ambition.

Of course it may not have worked out but sticking with the same regime hasn’t exactly been a success.
Like I said in hindsight it makes perfect sense but imagine making the change and still ending up here ( unlikely I know ) but if we had can you imagine all the why? If it's not broken don't fix it comments
 
Back
Top