The Second Greatest Season Ever

Kushiro2

Roofer
April 24th 2016. Leicester City v Swansea City. What a day.

There's never been an atmosphere quite like those closing minutes, with the chants spreading round all sides of the ground, '4-0 to the one man team!’ merging into ‘Barcelona – we're coming for you!'

That carnival mood had been set two hours earlier, with this wonderful Union FS tifo:

union fs 1925 5.png

All the trophies we'd won are lined up there at the bottom, starting with the Second Division Shield in 1925.

This season marks the centenary of that first silverware, and I want to try something I’m not sure has been attempted before. I’d like to recreate that season ‘in real time’, following it game by game, exactly 100 years ago to the day.

Of Fossils and Foxes has an excellent summary of that season, but the full story needs to be told. If 2015/16 was our greatest ever season, 1924/25 is the second best. It marked the birth of Leicester’s first great side, our first trophy - and nearly so much more than that. If, as the tifo said, History really does Make Us Who We Are, these events are right at the heart of the club's identity.

I'm going to approach each part of the story from the perspective of a different character - and we start with a 13-year-old boy who was about to enjoy an extraordinary eight months.


Saturday August 30th 1924

Harold Lineker was awoken by the familiar sound of his father’s early morning departure. George was up and out of the house before sunrise, heading for the Wholesale Market in Yeoman Street, a short distance from their house in Northampton Street. There he would begin the daily routine of carting fruit and vegetables to the stall in the Market Place, 300 yards away.

Harold was approaching his fourteenth birthday. He’d sometimes help his father on the stall, but there were other demands on his time. He was crazy about football, and he played outside right for his school team, St. George’s.

It was a very small world, as you can see on the map below. The circles mark the stall, the wholesale market at the top, the school, next to the church from which it took its name, and his home just below that. A few years later, Charles Street, which you can see was then just a minor road, would blast through those buildings on Humberstone Gate and the character of the area would be changed forever.

Lineker map northampton street circles.png

There was no football pitch in the cramped centre of the city, of course, and when the school had a game, the boys had to drag the goalposts all the way to Welford Road Recreation Ground. Good practice, no doubt, for future years when Harold would be the one hauling the fruit and veg cart through the streets.

The season began, as ever, with new dreams.

He was hoping his performances for St.George’s would get him selected for the Leicester Boys team. If so, perhaps he could help them achieve something no Leicester team had managed before, and make it through the qualifying rounds of the English Schools Trophy.


Harold loved to watch football too, and when school fixtures allowed, he'd be at Filbert Street to follow his heroes in the blue of Leicester City.

Perhaps this season they would be promoted for the first time in his life. Maybe they could even lift a trophy - something they hadn't managed in the 40 years since the club was formed. It was time they had a run in the FA Cup too. They’d never got beyond the quarter-final stage.

In the season just ended, Arthur Chandler had scored 24 times in his first season with the club, though we managed only a mid-table finish. Manager Peter Hodge was about start his sixth season in charge.

These were the twenty two teams in Division Two:

teams.png

Manchester United and The Wednesday, the only teams in the division who had won the League title, were favourites for promotion. Derby County and Chelsea were also strongly fancied. Not many mentioned Leicester.

Our season started with the toughest possible fixture - a trip to Old Trafford.

With regular full back Adam Black injured, this is how we lined up, in an orthodox 2-3-5 formation:

man u away g.png
man u away fb.png
man u away hb.png
man u away f.png

In the United team were Arthur Lochhead, future Leicester player and manager, and Sep Smith's older brother, Tom 'Tosser' Smith (his wikipedia page says he was called 'Tosher', but no - 'Tosser' is what his friends and teammates called him).

When the match kicked off, it was Lochhead who had the best early chance, his shot hitting 'the underpart of the bar', as the report put it. Then United got a dodgy penalty when Joe Spence 'fell over Johnny Duncan's feet'. The Leicester Evening Mail reporter, failing to hide his disgust, described it like this:

Spence fell with dramatic effect. He then limped to the side with the trainer's aid, as though he'd been seriously hurt. He remained inactive until the goal had been scored, then recovered.

In the second half, we laid siege to United's goal: In pace, craft and combinaiton, Leicester outplayed the home eleven. At least four times, shots flashed across the United goal with the defence utterly beaten (that's from the Athletic News, the paper based in Manchester).

We couldn't score though, and 1-0 was the final result. Everyone agreed that United had been lucky to win.

It's unclear how many Leicester fans were at Old Trafford - probably just a couple of hundred. At Filbert Street that afternoon it was a different matter. Almost 10,000 turned up to see the Reserves beat Peterborough and Fletton United. The local press thought it might be the highest ever gate for a second team match.

That gate needs a bit of explaining. For a brief period in the mid-20s our Reserves played in the Southern League Eastern Division, and our visitors that day were the reigning champions. We'd finished just a point behind in second place, so this game was the clash of the big two.

At Reserve games there was the added bonus of finding out how the first team got on as soon as the game finished. At 4.40, the bad news from Manchester was announced, and fans would have streamed out of the ground thinking 'It's the hope that kills you'.

Many would have headed for the centre of town, passing through the market, George Lineker picking up the news by word of mouth and hoping it wouldn't ruin Harold's weekend too much.

By 5.30, people would be snapping up copies of the Sports Paper, eagerly scanning the results:

aug 30 results.png

Stand-out scorelines were the impressive away wins for newly promoted Portsmouth and Wolves, and Derby's ominous looking trouncing of Hull CIty.

Leicester had started with a defeat, but everyone who saw the game at Old Trafford could see the potential in the side. The directors, who had final say in team selection, had no doubts. They immediately decided to stick with the same XI for the next game. That was just two days away, on Monday evening, with Chelsea the first visitors to Filbert Street.
 
Last edited:
Well I said this kind of thing may not have been attempted before, and there may be a good reason for that. It may simply not be a very good idea! Can you recreate the unfolding drama of the season, the endless swings between hope and despair, when the final outcome is already known?

Hopefully, the stories along the way are fascinating enough to make it all worthwhile. All being well I'll be posting them over on foxestalk once a week.
 
Interesting how the attendances were reported, all rounded off to a thousand, do you know how they counted them back then, on the clicks on the turnstiles or just estimated them?
 
Fascinating. I look forward to following that season. Whether 24/25 was ‘our second greatest season ever’ is a claim that I’ll be intrigued to see you stand up. By any measure, it was a landmark season, not least because it took us out of the ‘also ran’ category we’d languished in for much of our existence since 1884. But ‘second greatest’ is a tag that, to my mind, could easily apply to 28/29 (missing out on the Div One title by one point, with a better goal average than the Champions (The Wednesday), the famous 10-0 (6-0 Channy) biggest league win, the most top flight goals by a player in a top flight season (Chandler, 34), the combined strike force of Chandler, Lochhead and Hine (all three still comfortably in the Club’s top ten all time goal scorers), only City squad with five England internationals (and Channy missing out, inexplicably), a narrow fifth round defeat to the eventual FA Cup Winners). The Second Greatest claim could also be made for the 1962/3 season, or at a big stretch, 1999/2000, or dare I say it 2020/21 (although it didn’t feel like it, at all, after the Slavia Prague game, or most of all, the final whistle against the Spuds, following that Devon Loch style collapse in all but one of the last few games).
 
Fanatastic summary there. Love how you include 1999/2000. The only other one I'd chuck in would be 1953/54 (and maybe 1893/94, when footy fever really arrived for the first time).
 
Well, I said I was going to put these stories over on that 'other' messageboard, but hey, it doesn't take long to put them here too so that's what I'll try and do. I'll use the heading below for the main entries to distinguish them from any other posts I put on the thread.

100 years 4.png

Match 2 Leicester City v Chelsea Monday September 1st 1924

1924/25 would be full of bright spots for Leicester, but several dark shadows would fall across the season. We'll learn shortly about the collision that ended the career of Leicester's keeper, and ended the life of the opposition striker. We'll unearth the forgotten story of the expert stone mason who, having worked on the Cenotaph in London, was invited to Leicester to display his talents on the city's own war memorial, only to be caught up in another tragic and fatal accident.

Work on that magnificent memorial in Victoria Park had only just begun, and as the season progressed, the structure gradually grew in size, drawing gasps from people heading into town from the south. It would be completed in the spring as the season reached its climax, ready for the official opening in the summer of 1925.

The solemn mood was there right at the start of the season. As Leicester City ran out for their first home game, two days after the defeat at Old Trafford, the atmosphere of excitement was tempered by events of recent days. On Saturday night, a crowded bus in Nuneaton caught fire as the driver was trying to refill the petrol tank through the nozzle under his seat. He was not using a funnel, and a passenger lit a match, thinking it would help the driver to see where he was pouring.

Eight people perished in the flames. The tragedy would hasten legislation requiring all buses to have emergency exits at the rear, and refilling nozzles placed on the outside of vehicles.

A week earlier, England international footballer Tommy Meehan had died from inflammation of the brain, at the age of just 28. It was a devastating blow for everyone at his club - Chelsea, who were Leicester City's visitors for this Filbert Street opener.

You can see Meehan on the right, with Chelsea's other England internationals Benjamin Howard Baker (the amateur keeper) and Jack Cock:

Howard Baker Jack Cock Tommy Meehan.png

Before the match at Filbert Street there was a collection for Meehan's family, while at the same time twenty miles away, a collection for relatives of the victims of the bus tragedy was held before Nuneaton's friendly match against Coventry City.

Chelsea had just been relegated from Division One, and had started life in Division Two with a 1-0 win at Highfield Road.

When the game kicked off, Leicester continued the form they'd shown on Saturday, and a Chelsea handball gave Arthur Chandler a chance to put City ahead from the spot. Howard Baker was facing him. He was famous not just for his goalkeeping, but also for representing Great Britain in the high jump at the Olympics, and he made a 'spectacular leap across his goal' to reach the kick. Still we awaited our first goal of the season.

Then just before half time, Hugh Adcock finally made the breakthrough:

LEM Sep 2.png

Twenty minutes into the second half, Channy made it two:

Merc Sep 2.png

Those two clippings are from the two remaining dailies in the City - the Mail (Adcock's goal) and the Mercury (Chandler's) They were both evening papers - Leicester no longer had a local morning paper, the Daily Post having ceased publication in 1921.

George Carr added two late goals for City and the match finished 4-0. 'But for the brilliance of Baker in goal' said one report, 'Chelsea would have been made a laughing stock'.

The ground was 'crowded as for a Cup tie', said the Mail, estimating the gate at 25,000. That same afternoon, just a few hundred spectators were at the Aylestone Road cricket ground where Leicestershire were playing their last fixture of the season in the County Championship against Essex. Many would have left the ground early and made the short walk down Brazil Street in time for the kick-off at the football. One local journalist did the same:

footy cricket.png

This was how the two venues looked at that time, with the 'wings' still to be added to the Filbert Street Main Stand:

original 1923 photo.jpg

Here's a close up that shows the wonderful old Spion Kop with those 'herrings in a barrel' (the photo is from January 1923, with the Leicester v Fulham FA Cup tie in progress - another game when West London opponents were handed a 4-0 hammering):

1923 1.PNG

The Kop would be packed again five days later. Middlesbrough, the other relegated club last season, would be the next visitors to Filbert Street.
 
Last edited:
100 years 4.png


Match 3 Saturday September 6th 1924 Leicester City v Middlesbrough

A week after an unlucky defeat at Old Trafford in the opener, we lost out against United again today, even though we weren't actually playing them.

The game against Boro' at Filbert Street turned on an incident early in the first half when the referee, Mr. Slater of Blackburn, made what the Leicester Mail called 'the mistake of a lifetime'. Arthur Chandler took a free kick from just outside the box. His shot flew into the top corner, hit the iron support at the back of the goal and bounced back out. No goal was given.

Leicester players surrounded the ref and 'for some minutes he was subjected to considerable barracking'. But he wouldn't even consult his linesman.

It wasn't Channy's day. He later missed several chances and the match finished 0-0.

At the Victoria Ground that afternoon there was another controversial incident. Stoke got the ball in the net and the referee signaled a goal. Manchester United players surrounded the referee and urged him to consult his linesman. This he did, and the goal was chalked off, the ball judged to have crossed the goal line before it was crossed. It finished 0-0 there too.

Had those decisions gone the other way we'd have been two points ahead of the promotion favourites. Instead, we were side by side, as fans discovered in the sports paper that evening where the first League table of the season was published:

sep 6 table.png

It was Derby's draw at Portsmouth that made them the early leaders, with no team having a 100% record, and every team having at least a point.

Leicester's next fixture would be on Monday evening - the return fixture against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge. We wouldn't be wearing our blue shirts, of course. We'd have to change to our red away kit.

That's a good moment to show you the home colours of every team in Division Two that season:

kits 1.png

kits 2.png

kits 3.png

kits 4 again.png

kits 5.png

kits 6.png

(thanks to the marvelous historicalkits.co.uk)
 
This is brilliant as ever and a great read.
For me personally, 1962/63 was our second best season.
Our tactics were noted and copied by the managerial greats.
The year Liverpool first sang YNWA, after defeat by us...
The Ice Kings...
4th in the League and FA Cup Finalists and probably would have won both, had there not been key injuries at the tail end of the season.
 
This is brilliant as ever and a great read.
For me personally, 1962/63 was our second best season.
Our tactics were noted and copied by the managerial greats.
The year Liverpool first sang YNWA, after defeat by us...
The Ice Kings...
4th in the League and FA Cup Finalists and probably would have won both, had there not been key injuries at the tail end of the season.
1953 thought we might be champions that year. LIZ came to the throne, had my call up papers to go for a medical as well
King Arthur reigned supreme broke his own record for the most goals in a Season.
First time ever going to Goodison Park and watched two superb games against them.
The home game I nearly didn't get in my mate Barry lost some money and we were scrambling around trying to see where it all happened, we found the cash in the turn ups of his trousers, just managed to squeeze in the turnstyle just as they were shutting,
Little did we know that we would be even better the next Season
 
Interesting how the attendances were reported, all rounded off to a thousand, do you know how they counted them back then, on the clicks on the turnstiles or just estimated them?
Well l know for a fact the turnstiles clicked in 1944 but my granddad always said the turnstiles were open to abuse
 
The 56/57 season we gained promotion to Div 1
The final game of the season was at Filbert St against Leyton Orient, they clapped us onto the field, then stuffed us 4-1. Legend has it that our players were still pissed after a week celebrating.
The Div 2 Shield was presented after the game.

I was at that game and is the first City game that I can place in time and remember specific incidents, games before that, and I saw a few, were just vague impressions.

I was lifted over the turnstile and sat on my dad’s knee. His season ticket was in the ‘Wing Stand’ level with the D at the Kop end.
I was 6 years old.
 
Wasn't lifted over the turnstile but we passed hand to hand to sit on the white wall when l was 6 or 7 virtually every match l went to
 
100 years 4.png

Match 4
Monday September 8th 1924
Chelsea v Leicester City

The current season, 2024/25, kicked off shortly after the Closing Ceremony of the Olympic Games in Paris. 100 years ago, it was just the same.

Back then the likes of break dancing and beach volleyball were not, of course, part of the Olympic programme, but there was a whole category of events that today seem equally exotic. Medals were awarded not only in sports, but also for the arts.

In the 'music' category, the judging panel was made up of a dazzling array of famous figures, including Bela Bartok, Gabriel Faure, Maurice Ravel and Igor Stravinsky. After spending hours and hours listening patiently to the compositions of lesser mortals, they decided that NONE of the entrants was worthy of a medal.

Good on them.

What a pity that, along with the Olympic Arts programme, this approach to judging is no longer with us. How wonderful it would be if, after the World Cup Final or Champions League Final, a similar panel of judges had the right to declare that NEITHER side deserved the honours. No trophy, no medals, no pyrotechnic presentation ceremony.

Of course, 80, 000 people in the stadium might feel a little put out, but the long term benefits could only be positive. No more cagey, ultra-defensive bore-draws followed by a tedious extra half hour and penalty lottery. Teams would have to come out and play, and show they were really worthy of the title 'Best Team in the World' or 'Champions of Europe'.

We can all think of matches that deserved this brutal assessment. And we'd all have our dream candidates for that judging panel. With allowance for a bit of resurrection, I'd go for Johan Cruyff, Bill Shankly and Cesar Luis Menotti.

The judges in the 'architecture' category in Paris 1924 were scarcely more charitable. They too decided that no entry was worthy of a gold medal, but they did hand out a silver medal to a pair from Hungary, who presented the design for a football stadium.

This was it:

hung.png

Now if only Archibald Leitch had entered, there might have been a portfolio worthy of a gold medal.

More than any other person, Leitch was responsible for the way British football grounds looked in 1924. In Division Two, the designs of more than half the grounds had come from his drawing board. Filbert Street itself had been given the Leitch treatment back in the Fosse era (though it's not the case, as is claimed on his wikipedia page, that he designed the Double Decker).

When we ran out for the opening game of the season, it was at the Leitch-designed Old Trafford. That same day in South London saw the opening of the ground Leitch had laid out for Crytal Palace:

AN Sep 1.png

Leicester City would be one of the first visitors to Selhurst Park, the fixture scheduled for October.

But now on September 8th, for our second away trip, we headed for another of Leitch's colossal arenas - Stamford Bridge, which like Old Trafford had recently staged the FA Cup Final.


It's A Funny Game

Chelsea were hoping to get instant revenge for that 4-0 defeat at Filbert Street seven days earlier. On Saturday they'd won 5-0 at Oldham, with Bill Whitton getting a hat-trick. Whitton would be the central character again today.

Twenty minutes into the game, he was involved in a collision with keeper Bert Godderidge, leaving the City man badly hurt. He decided to stay on the field, though 'he could barely move across the goal' (the quaint idea of substitutions was still four decades away).

Whitton soon put Chelsea one up with a header that Godderidge would normally have stopped. Then at the other end Chandler was through one-on-one with the keeper and looked certain to equalise. That is, until Chelsea captain Jack Harrow stetched out both arms and cynically hauled him to the ground. All City got was a free kick (the quaint idea of professional fouls meriting a sending off was still six decades away).

1920s football did have something going for it, though. The home supporters responded to this incident in a way we'd never see today. The Chelsea captain was roundly booed by his own supporters.

That free kick came to nothing, and shortly after, Whitton added a second with a shot that, once again, Godderidge might have saved had he been fully mobile.

2-0 was the half-time score, and Godderidge, like Mark Wallington in 1982, decided there'd been enough heroics. He didn't appear for the second half and we played the rest of the game with ten men, left half Norman Watson taking over in goal.

Whitton added two more in the second half, taking his tally to seven in just 48 hours. We had our chances, but couldn't get past that Olympic high-jumper in goal. This is how Benjamin Howard Baker was portrayed on the cover of the match programme that day:

BHB Sep 8 2.png

4-0 is how it ended - an exact reverse of the score at Filbert Street. 'It's a funny game', the Leicester Mercury commented.

But not funny ha-ha. With just three points from four games, our promotion campaign had got off to a miserable start. In three out of the four games we could point to bad luck, but in each of those games we'd failed to score. Channy had managed just a single goal so far.

With Stoke due at Filbert Street five days later, the pressure was on.
 
Wasn't lifted over the turnstile but we passed hand to hand to sit on the white wall when l was 6 or 7 virtually every match l went to
A few years later, too big to sit with my dad, I would go with my mates family on the popular side. Kids were regularly passed through to the front to sit on the wall.

Once the players were on the pitch you had to sit with your legs on the inside of the wall so you were watching over your shoulder,one way or the other. The prized positions were those behind the boards that displayed the half time scores, you could sit facing the play with legs behind the board, luxury.
 
A few years later, too big to sit with my dad, I would go with my mates family on the popular side. Kids were regularly passed through to the front to sit on the wall.

Once the players were on the pitch you had to sit with your legs on the inside of the wall so you were watching over your shoulder,one way or the other. The prized positions were those behind the boards that displayed the half time scores, you could sit facing the play with legs behind the board, luxury.
 
As a nine year old going down and sitting on the wall in the Kop I could never understand why they made you sit like that!
 
By the end of the 50’s the rules were strict. The moment the players emerged the stewards made everyone tuck their legs on the inside of the wall, no arguments in those days. Some lads would be waiting outside when the gates opened and run into position to get a coveted place behind the scoreboard, where you could sit facing the game.

A few years later the family moved to the enclosure in front of the main stand, close to the tunnel. My mate and I would stand with the family until just before kickoff and then walk around and go into the Kop. That corner where the enclosure met the Kop was wide open, no barriers, nothing, you could walk round and stand wherever you wanted, easy enough most games.
 
By the end of the 50’s the rules were strict. The moment the players emerged the stewards made everyone tuck their legs on the inside of the wall, no arguments in those days. Some lads would be waiting outside when the gates opened and run into position to get a coveted place behind the scoreboard, where you could sit facing the game.

A few years later the family moved to the enclosure in front of the main stand, close to the tunnel. My mate and I would stand with the family until just before kickoff and then walk around and go into the Kop. That corner where the enclosure met the Kop was wide open, no barriers, nothing, you could walk round and stand wherever you wanted, easy enough most games.
That's very true you could near enough walk around Filbo apart from the Tunnel
 
That's very true you could near enough walk around Filbo apart from the Tunnel
Not quite the case.
The enclosure in front of the main stand (south) was continuous round the corner and into the Kop, one enclosure from the tunnel to where the Kop joined the Popular side.
The barrier in that corner was to stop anyone paying the lower price for the popular side then walking into the Kop.
There was a smaller enclosure in front of the main stand (north) that I only went into once or twice, can’t remember whether you could walk round behind the goal at that end.
The 68/69 season was my last as a regular supporter. Off to Uni in September only a few dozen games since then.
 
I did it around 45/46 the main and south stand stood in bomb damage till the late 40's. I saw the fire from my bedroom window
as it overlooked the LNER line and the small lake in front of the shunting yard, that ran to the shed
 
My first game between Xmas and New Year 73 , sat on the wall in the pop side all the fences were already in at the time.
Pop side in 3 parts and the Kop in 4 pens
 
In the mid 50s my father cycled to the ground with me in a child seat. The houses in Burnmore St had bike racks in the back yard, a few pence to store your bike and a cup of tea, Bovril in mid winter.
Can’t date this but if I was in the child’s seat on the bike it can’t have been later than 56/7, perhaps a year or two earlier.

My first game between Xmas and New Year 73 , sat on the wall in the pop side all the fences were already in at the time.
Pop side in 3 parts and the Kop in 4 pens
The fences, the pens were the death of the ‘live’ experience for me.
By this time I was going to Stamford bridge when I could, this was the Osgood, Hollins, Hutchinson era, some epic battles against Leeds in the aftermath of that cup final!
Still able to turn up on the day, stand at the shed end no problem, not for much longer though.
 
100 years 4.png

Match 5
Saturday September 13th 2024
Leicester City v Stoke

For a short time after World War 1, Leicester could boast something that Stoke could not - it was officially a 'city'. After King George V's visit to Leicester in 1919, the change was announced, with the name of the football club following almost immediately afterwards.Then in 1925 the King visited the Potteries and he himself broke the news of a similar change in status. Shortly after that, the local football club became 'Stoke City'.

So this was the last time they visited Filbert Street as plain old 'Stoke'.

Before the game, we were 14th, Stoke 15th - we really needed two points to start moving up the table. Rain kept the crowd down to about 15,000 - and the ones who did turn up were in for a miserable afternoon. Ten minutes into the game, the rain suddenly got much heavier, and thanks to defective guttering on the roof of the Main Stand, people standing below were drenched.

It was goalless at half time, and though we had most of the play, we were still suffering from 'that fatal habit of hesitation before goal'. Then Channy had the chance of the game. He was right through - but 'slipped on the wet grass' and the chance was gone.

Stoke then broke away and with their only chance of the game, Len Armitage put the ball in the net. 'By every rule of chance or probablility they deserved nothing', said the Mail. But they won 1-0. We couldn't blame the awful weather. In Derby and Manchester conditions were the same, but the Rams beat Fulham 5-1 and United beat Coventry by the same score. This was how the top of the table looked that evening:

sep 13.png

Leicester slipped to 17th. A relegation battle now looked more likely than a challenge for promotion. Two days later another Monday evening fixture was scheduled - away to Stockport County, who'd made a fine start, as you can see from that table.

The directors knew something had to change - and they were about to make a crucial decision.
 
If I remember rightly, season 73-74, it was 50p in the kop, 25p for juniors but the juniors could only get in to pen 1 or pen 4 which meant to get into pen 2 or 3 you had to scale the fence from the outside pens.
I ruined more than one pair of jeans/Oxford bags doing this & climbing over in platform shoes was a challenge.
 
Back
Top